European Football’s Fan Disorder Problem: Are Sanctions Strong Enough?

Fan violence is rearing its ugly head again in European football. The recent incident at Villa Park, where Aston Villa’s Europa League match against Young Boys was marred by projectiles thrown at players and clashes in the stands, highlights a worrying trend. Donyell Malen, Dortmund’s striker, even suffered a cut to the head. It’s a stark reminder that the beautiful game can quickly turn ugly.

Young Boys, it’s worth noting, aren’t exactly strangers to this sort of trouble. They were just finishing up a two-year probation for prior misconduct at a Champions League game against Manchester City. Add to that a separate suspended punishment for fireworks, and you’ve got a club with a clear pattern of fan-related issues. Now, they’re likely facing fresh charges and will be on the hook for repair costs at Villa Park.
>

The escalation of these incidents prompts a crucial question: why does this keep occurring?

Since football’s return following the pandemic, fan disorder seems to have grown. Arrests in England and Wales have surged, hitting a nine-year peak in 2023, and the numbers have kept climbing in the seasons since. However, it’s interesting that, so far this season, no Premier League team appears on UEFA’s disciplinary list. England currently ranks sixth in Europe concerning supporter conduct. Does this suggest that the UK is dealing with the problem effectively? Or is it merely hiding beneath the surface?

Elsewhere in Europe, we see high-profile incidents involving racism, violence, and unsafe fan behavior. However, the punishments are inconsistently applied. While UEFA has issued numerous stadium bans for racist or discriminatory acts, some clubs still get off with what many consider to be lenient fines, even for serious offenses. The controversy surrounding relatively minor penalties for racist abuse in games involving Qarabag and Atletico Madrid sticks in the mind.
>

These inconsistencies undermine any serious effort to curb fan misbehavior. If the punishments don’t hurt, what’s stopping anyone?

The Villa Park incident also opens the door to a discussion about how we assess risk when allocating tickets to visiting fans. It’s a valid point. Maccabi Tel Aviv supporters, for instance, were barred from traveling to Villa Park earlier this month because of earlier acts of violence and the underlying tensions relating to the Israel-Gaza crisis. Despite a history of problematic behavior, Young Boys fans were still allowed entry. Did someone drop the ball on the risk assessment?

That leads us to a fundamental issue: are the current sanctions powerful enough to serve as a real deterrent? Too often, it feels like we’re slapping wrists when a stronger hand is needed.

Having watched these cycles unfold over the years, here’s my take. Fines, stadium closures, even bans – they’re just treating the symptoms. To truly tackle this problem, we need a multi-pronged strategy that addresses the root causes of fan violence.

Here’s what that might involve:

Stricter Liability for Clubs: Clubs must be held more accountable for the actions of their supporters. Financial penalties alone aren’t enough. Perhaps points deductions, especially for repeat offenders, could send a stronger message. Enhanced Security Measures: Increased security presence at stadiums, more thorough searches, and the use of technology like facial recognition could help identify and prevent troublemakers from entering grounds. Targeted Education Programs: Clubs and football associations should invest in educational programs that promote respect, tolerance, and responsible behavior among fans. These programs should target young supporters and address issues like racism and discrimination. Collaboration with Law Enforcement: Closer collaboration between clubs, law enforcement agencies, and fan groups can help share information, identify potential risks, and develop effective strategies for managing crowd behavior. A Transparent and Consistent Sanctioning Process: UEFA needs to ensure that sanctions are applied consistently across all leagues and competitions. The reasoning behind disciplinary decisions should be transparent, so fans and clubs understand the consequences of their actions. Ban perpetrators: A life ban from any stadium to people who engage in violence or racist abuse is necessary.

It’s a complex puzzle, and there’s no easy fix. Yet, ignoring the problem is not an option. The events at Villa Park should serve as a wake-up call. If European football doesn’t take decisive action now, we risk seeing a return to the dark days of hooliganism, which would damage the sport and alienate true fans. We need something concrete, something that sends a strong, clear message: fan disorder will not be tolerated.

I hope to see real change. The sport deserves better, and the safety of players and supporters must be the top priority.

Read Original

Keywords: European football fan disorder, fan violence sanctions, Aston Villa fan trouble, football hooliganism, UEFA disciplinary action, racism in football, stadium bans football, football security measures