A Heisman Trophy voter has publicly criticized Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia for his expletive-laden reaction to not winning the prestigious award. Chase Goodbread, a voter for The Tuscaloosa News, penned a scathing column detailing his disappointment with Pavia’s post-election social media outburst. Pavia reportedly posted “F— all the voters” on an Instagram story after finishing a distant second to Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza.
Goodbread, in his commentary, argued that Pavia, as a seasoned college athlete with multiple degrees and NIL earnings, should possess the maturity to handle criticism and the outcome of the Heisman voting. He characterized Pavia’s reaction as “jackassery” and a “punk move,” suggesting that after six years in college, Pavia should have learned a degree of humility. The voter emphasized that while he was not present at the ceremony, his congratulations to Mendoza were genuine.
Vanderbilt’s Athletic Director, Candice Lee, released a statement acknowledging Pavia’s actions were “unacceptable” and that he had apologized. Lee expressed that Pavia was contrite and regretted the hurt caused, but stressed the responsibility that comes with representing Vanderbilt University. The statement also indicated the university’s commitment to growth and accountability, pledging continued support for Pavia.
Pavia himself later issued an apology on X, admitting he did not handle his emotions well and failed to represent himself as intended. He expressed deep respect for Heisman voters and the selection process, calling his outburst a mistake. Pavia specifically acknowledged Fernando Mendoza as a deserving winner and also extended respect to other finalists Jeremiyah Love and Julian Sayin.
In his apology, Pavia reflected on his journey, noting a history of being doubted and having to fight for opportunities. He credited his family, teammates, coaches, and staff for their unwavering support. Pavia concluded by stating his eagerness to compete one last time in the ReliaQuest Bowl with his team, aiming to prevent distractions.
Pavia concluded his collegiate regular season as a standout performer, leading the SEC with a 71.2% completion rate. He amassed 3,192 passing yards and 27 touchdowns, adding nine rushing scores and 826 rushing yards on 152 attempts. This performance came in his second season with Vanderbilt, following his transfer from New Mexico State.
Keywords: Diego Pavia, Heisman Trophy, Fernando Mendoza, Vanderbilt quarterback, Heisman voter, college football awards, college athlete maturity, Vanderbilt athletics

